The Value of Drilling Down in Service Departments

In service departments, reaching consistent profitability and high Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) or Net Promoter Scores (NPS) often requires a deeper analysis than a superficial glance at monthly reports. When seeking to elevate performance metrics, simply reviewing KPIs like those from Dealer Management Systems (DMS), manufacturer reports, or third-party vendors may provide an overview but rarely offers actionable insights. A deeper dive—or “drilling down”—can reveal what might otherwise go unnoticed, helping managers uncover opportunities for growth and efficiency without an information overload.

Assessing Customer Dependency

One of the first areas to assess is your dependency on different customer types. Specifically, understanding the reliance on warranty and internal work compared to customer-paid (CP) hours can reveal much about your service department’s revenue structure. If customer-paid work is lagging, there may be a chance to optimize this area by analyzing specific metrics, such as:

• Items per CP Repair Order (RO): How many items are typically addressed in a single customer visit?
• Single-Item CP ROs: Are a significant percentage of repair orders limited to just one item?
• CP Work Mix: Do you see more competitive maintenance services or repairs?
• Menu Sales Success: How effectively is your department converting opportunities for recommended maintenance into actual sales?

Other essential elements to review include effective labor rate (ELR), repair pricing grid utilization, and any internal or external factors influencing CP performance. With tools like ROSE+, our repair order survey and evaluation tool, gathering and breaking down RO data to reveal these critical metrics becomes seamless, allowing you to pinpoint areas for potential improvement with clarity and precision.

Leveraging Labor Sales Sources

Labor sales in a service department generally come from two key sources: point-of-sale (POS) recommendations and post-diagnostic work. Advisors can suggest services based on mileage, time since the last service, or visible wear, while technicians may recommend additional work after performing diagnostics or multi-point inspections. Maximizing CP revenue requires a balanced approach, ensuring that both initial recommendations and diagnostic-driven recommendations are utilized to their fullest.

Creating a Baseline for Performance Improvement

Before embarking on significant changes, it’s crucial to establish a clear baseline across various KPIs. An initial analysis could look like this:

• CP Hours Per RO (HPRO): 1.4
• Items per CP RO: 1.2
• Single-Item CP ROs: 48.5%
• Menu Sales Success: 12.5%
• Average Mileage: 68,750 miles
• Percentage of CP ROs > 30,000 miles: 95%

These figures provide a starting point to identify areas where performance may be lacking. Setting realistic, achievable goals for each KPI—such as a 60% target for menu sales success—gives the team clear objectives to work toward.

Optimizing Menu Sales Opportunities

Menu sales can often serve as a foundational element for revenue growth. By increasing menu sales, a service department can positively impact other KPIs, like the number of items per CP RO and the percentage of single-item ROs. To capitalize on menu sales opportunities, identify vehicles at or near major mileage intervals, utilize factory recommendations, and ensure dealership recommendations align with manufacturer standards.

Identifying and Addressing Obstacles to Sales

During this review, engaging with advisors and technicians to understand any perceived obstacles is invaluable. Common challenges might include:

• Outdated or inaccurate menu prices
• Limited shop capacity for same-day services
• Discrepancies between in-store and online menu offerings

Addressing these issues ensures advisors have confidence in recommending services, while technicians can rely on the pricing structure to be accurate and timely. When team members align on menu content and pricing, they’re better equipped to enhance sales performance organically.

Measuring and Sharing Results

Once adjustments are in place, maintaining focus on measurement is critical. Regularly reviewing results with your team fosters a culture of accountability and keeps everyone on the same page. Whether through weekly meetings or individual performance reviews, sharing successes and identifying areas for further improvement promotes a disciplined approach to sustaining growth. This consistency is key to making menu presentations and increased sales part of the department’s routine, ultimately bringing up profitability and CSI/NPS.

The Role of Technology in Enhanced Analysis

If the current DMS or reporting tools don’t support this level of detail, manual review of repair orders is one option. Alternatively, consider digital solutions like our ROSE+ program, an electronic repair order survey tool that provides real-time insights and streamlines data gathering from the DMS. This tool can reduce the manual workload and offers precise data to help inform decisions on improvements.

Commitment to Consistency and Accountability

Regularly examining KPIs and addressing any identified challenges shows a commitment to improvement that goes beyond basic metrics. By fostering a disciplined, methodical approach to performance, managers can create an environment where both revenue and CSI/NPS are consistently on the rise.

Customer Pay Hours and Labor Rate Optimization

A critical focus for improving the profitability of fixed operations lies in enhancing customer pay (CP) hours and optimizing labor rates. Breaking down CP hours per repair order and effective labor rates (ELR) into competitive, maintenance, and repair categories can provide a clear snapshot of areas with growth potential. In many cases, adjusting pricing strategies based on competitive analysis, service complexity, or regional market conditions can result in a higher effective labor rate across these categories, creating a stronger profit margin on customer pay work.

• CP Hours Per RO: Increasing the hours per RO not only raises revenue but also reflects the department’s ability to provide comprehensive service.
• Effective Labor Rate Segmentation: Maintaining varied labor rates for competitive services versus repairs or maintenance can help position the dealership favorably against competitors while maximizing profitability in high-skill repair work.

To drive these KPIs, consider regular training sessions for advisors and technicians on time and mileage-based recommendations, using data from past services to guide proactive service suggestions.

Building Trust Through Transparency in Service Recommendations

An often-overlooked factor in boosting sales is the trust relationship between customers and advisors. Customers are more likely to accept recommendations when they understand the “why” behind each suggestion. By implementing transparent service recommendation practices, advisors can gain customer trust, which can lead to higher approval rates for recommended services. Here’s how:

• Show the Evidence: Advisors should walk customers through findings, whether from multi-point inspections or specific diagnostic results. Visual aids, such as photos or videos of their vehicle’s condition, can enhance understanding and build credibility.
• Educate on Preventive Maintenance: Educating customers on the benefits of preventive maintenance not only positions the dealership as a knowledgeable authority but can also reduce vehicle downtime for customers, enhancing overall satisfaction.
• Clear Pricing Models: An upfront, straightforward pricing structure with itemized explanations for each service type minimizes surprises, fostering trust and comfort in accepting service recommendations.

Leveraging Data to Improve Customer Retention

Data plays a powerful role in improving customer retention. Analyzing customer demographics, average vehicle age, and visit frequency allows managers to tailor marketing and service approaches that resonate with specific customer groups. By understanding customer behaviors, service departments can build retention strategies that keep customers coming back, which is essential for long-term growth.

• Targeted Marketing Campaigns: For example, creating maintenance reminders for customers based on mileage or time since their last visit can boost return rates for routine service.
• Customer Segmentation: Segmenting customers by factors such as vehicle age or average annual mileage enables more personalized service options, as some customers may benefit more from high-mileage services, while others may need only seasonal maintenance.

Implementing these tactics can increase customer loyalty, helping service departments mitigate reliance on warranty or internal work and develop a robust customer-paid revenue stream.

Streamlining Service Processes for Maximum Efficiency

Efficiency in a service department often correlates directly with customer satisfaction and profitability. Optimizing scheduling, reducing turnaround time, and minimizing parts delays can enhance overall workflow and service quality. By focusing on these core areas, managers can improve operational efficiency, allowing the team to handle higher volumes with less stress.

• Effective Scheduling Systems: Advanced scheduling systems that take into account technician availability, required skills, and estimated service time can reduce customer wait times and improve workflow.
• Inventory Management: An efficient parts inventory system ensures that commonly required parts are always on hand, preventing delays and lost revenue due to backorders.
• Minimizing Idle Time: Tracking technician time and identifying gaps in productive hours can reveal opportunities for training or process improvements, enhancing overall output and reducing idle periods.

An organized, efficient department allows staff to perform at their best, improving the customer experience and potentially increasing positive reviews, which can further boost department revenue through repeat business.

The Power of Incremental Improvements

Achieving higher profitability and CSI/NPS isn’t always about dramatic changes. In fact, incremental improvements in key areas often produce substantial gains over time. Establishing a culture of continuous improvement, where small, manageable goals are consistently set and achieved, can have a profound impact on department performance.

• Quarterly Goal Setting: Setting incremental, measurable goals for each quarter can keep the team motivated and aligned with the department’s objectives.
• Continuous Feedback Loops: Regularly meeting with team members to discuss progress and solicit feedback fosters a sense of shared responsibility and allows managers to make real-time adjustments to strategies.
• Celebrating Wins: Recognizing small victories, such as an improvement in menu sales success or a reduction in single-item ROs, reinforces the team’s efforts and keeps morale high.

Small, steady improvements in KPIs create a foundation for long-term success, as the cumulative effect of these changes ultimately contributes to substantial gains in performance and profitability.

Creating a Culture of Accountability and Team Engagement

Finally, the success of any strategy depends on the team’s buy-in and accountability. Service departments that cultivate a culture of accountability, where each team member is aware of their individual and collective contributions, tend to see more sustainable success. Engaged teams are more likely to take pride in their work, seek ways to improve, and stay committed to achieving departmental goals.

• Transparent KPI Tracking: By sharing department KPIs with the team, employees can see how their performance aligns with overall goals and identify areas where they can improve.
• Collaborative Problem-Solving: Engaging technicians and advisors in problem-solving discussions empowers them to take ownership of challenges and fosters a collaborative approach to achieving results.
• Ongoing Training and Development: Investing in training—whether in soft skills, such as customer communication, or technical skills, like diagnostics—shows the team that their growth is valued, leading to higher job satisfaction and retention.

In creating an environment where each team member understands the role they play in driving success, service departments can achieve a unified approach to reaching high levels of CSI/NPS and profitability.

---

Elevate your Fixed Operations department with our custom-tailored solutions. Our team offers in-depth assessments and specialized training programs, crafting strategies designed specifically to boost efficiency, maximize customer retention, and ensure long-term profitability. We’ll work closely with you to identify areas for improvement and implement targeted solutions that drive sustainable growth for your business.

Contact us today for a Free Consultation!