The Illusion of Extra Days: Rethinking Saturday’s Value

When dealerships open their service departments on Saturdays, the expectation is often clear: more availability will lead to more business. The math seems simple. If you’re open five days a week and add Saturdays, you’ve increased your availability by 20 percent. That should mean more revenue, right?

But here’s the problem. That logic only holds if Saturday carries the same weight as a weekday. In most service departments, it doesn’t. The hours are shorter. The technician headcount is lower. Certain types of work aren’t scheduled. And support staff may be stretched thin.

What looks like four full Saturdays on the calendar rarely adds up to four full workdays. In fact, in many shops, it doesn’t even equal two.

This misunderstanding can lead to a major disconnect between operational planning and actual performance. It affects scheduling, staffing, expenses, and ultimately, profitability. Many managers sense that something feels off, but without clear numbers, it’s hard to pinpoint the issue.

That’s why Saturday needs to be evaluated not by how often the doors are open, but by how much work actually gets done. A careful review of technician hours and capacity is the only way to understand what Saturdays are really contributing.

Most shops think they’re gaining four extra days. But once you calculate the real output, the story changes.

Ask the Right Questions About Your Saturday Operation

Before jumping into the math, you need to ask some basic but important questions. These are the questions that reveal whether Saturdays are being used to their full potential or if they’re quietly bleeding resources.

Start with operational hours. How many hours are you open on Saturday? How does that compare to a typical weekday?

Next, look at your technician staffing. How many techs are scheduled to work on Saturday? How many are in the shop during the week?

Now look at support. How many service advisors are scheduled? Do you have someone available to answer phones, check in customers, and follow up on declined work?

Do you provide lunch for Saturday staff? It’s a common practice to boost morale on the weekend, but it’s also an added cost.

Here’s another key question: can your team perform warranty work on Saturdays? If your manufacturer doesn’t allow it or if your policies discourage it, you’re limiting the scope of what can be done.

And finally, take a look at customer demand. When is your next available Saturday appointment? If you’re booked two or three weeks out, demand exists. But are you staffed to meet it?

These questions aren’t just for curiosity. They form the foundation for calculating your department’s real Saturday contribution. Without clear answers, you’re flying blind.

Too many shops treat Saturday like a bonus without checking whether it’s delivering bonus results. Asking the right questions is the first step toward making that assessment.

Calculating Average Monthly Workdays Without Saturdays

Let’s take a step back and look at the service calendar without Saturdays. Understanding your baseline work capacity helps you see what Saturdays could and should be contributing.

There are 365 days in a year. If your dealership closes every Saturday and Sunday, that removes 104 days. Add in roughly six major holidays, and you’re left with about 255 workdays each year.

Divide that by 12 months, and you get an average of 21.25 workdays per month.

This is your starting point. This is the capacity of your shop when it operates Monday through Friday. It assumes full staffing, regular hours, and normal workflow.

Now, when you decide to open on Saturdays, it’s tempting to simply add four more days to the calendar. That would suggest your average monthly workdays go from 21.25 to 25.25. But that only makes sense if each Saturday matches a weekday in productivity.

That’s rarely the case.

Most Saturday shifts are shorter. Most teams are reduced. Certain services might not be available. When you consider all these factors, the true value of each Saturday shrinks.

The problem is that many departments still plan their operations and set expectations based on the idea that Saturdays are full workdays. Budgets get built around that assumption. So do staffing models and customer promises.

But when the actual results come in, they fall short.

That’s not because the staff isn’t working hard. It’s because the structure of the day was never designed to support a full load. Until you know how to measure the real impact of each Saturday, it’s impossible to plan properly.

This brings us to the next step—calculating Saturday’s true contribution.

Introducing the Concept of ‘Saturday Contribution’

To understand what Saturdays really add to your monthly output, you need to look at them through two lenses: time and people.

Start with hours. If your shop runs eight hours per weekday but only five on Saturday, you’re working at 62.5 percent of normal time.

Then look at technician count. If you typically schedule ten technicians during the week but only five on Saturday, you’re operating at 50 percent of your normal workforce.

To find Saturday’s contribution, multiply these two percentages together. In this example:

62.5% x 50% = 31.25%

That means each Saturday is operating at roughly 31.25 percent of a normal workday.

Now multiply that by 52 Saturdays in a year:

52 x 31.25% = 16.25

That’s 16.25 full-equivalent workdays added per year. Divide by 12 months, and you get:

16.25 / 12 = 1.4 days per month

Let that sink in. You’re open four Saturdays a month. But because of reduced hours and staffing, they only equal 1.4 full days of work.

That’s a big gap. And it’s one most service departments haven’t accounted for.

This 1.4-day figure is what we call your Saturday contribution. It’s the real, measurable addition that Saturdays are making to your department’s monthly capacity.

It doesn’t mean Saturdays aren’t valuable. But it does mean you shouldn’t treat them like four full bonus days. Doing so will lead to unrealistic expectations and operational blind spots.

Once you understand the Saturday contribution, you can start making smarter decisions about staffing, scheduling, and service strategy. It’s about aligning expectations with reality.

You’re not failing if your Saturdays aren’t producing like weekdays. You’re only failing if you expect them to and don’t adjust your planning when they don’t.

Case Study: A Typical Underutilized Saturday

Let’s take the numbers used earlier and apply them to a real-life example.

Your service department is open from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. on Saturdays. That’s five hours. You typically operate from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. during the week, which is eight hours. That’s 62.5 percent of a full day in terms of time.

Now look at staffing. On a regular weekday, you have ten technicians scheduled. On Saturdays, you only have five. That’s 50 percent of your weekday workforce.

Multiply these two numbers:
62.5% of a day × 50% of your team = 31.25% of a full production day

Now apply that to all 52 Saturdays in a year.
52 × 31.25% = 16.25 full-day equivalents annually
Divide that by 12 months and you get about 1.4 days of true monthly production.

So even though you’re open four Saturdays a month, the net output is barely more than one additional workday. That’s a tough pill to swallow.

The gap between perception and performance is wide. Your team is stretched to cover the hours. Advisors are often juggling tasks they wouldn’t normally handle. Technicians might be bouncing between maintenance jobs without the structure or support they’re used to during the week.

And yet, because the shop is open, everyone assumes the same results are being achieved. They’re not.

This kind of misalignment can skew your production forecasts. It can also mask productivity issues. You may think Saturday is pulling its weight when it’s actually falling short.

The good news is this isn’t hard to fix. But first, it has to be acknowledged. A Saturday schedule needs to be assessed like any other part of your operation. That starts with understanding the numbers and the story they tell.

The Cost of a Half-Day Operation

Running a service department on Saturday isn’t free. Even if you’re only open five hours, you still need people in place. That includes technicians, advisors, parts support, and potentially shuttle drivers or porters.

If you’re buying lunch for the team, that’s another cost. It may be modest, but it adds up over time—especially if it’s built into your routine without checking the return.

And then there’s the missed work.

Some shops don’t allow warranty work on Saturdays. Others avoid bigger jobs, sticking to oil changes, tire rotations, and light maintenance. That limits your revenue potential from the start.

You might also be scheduling with gaps. Without full coverage at the front counter, it’s hard to handle walk-ins or late arrivals. That can lead to empty bays while customers are waiting.

Add to that the fact that most OEM and third-party support systems are closed or limited on weekends. That can cause delays in approvals, diagnostics, and parts availability.

Put it all together and you may find that your most expensive day, per technician hour worked, is Saturday.

It’s not that Saturdays can’t be profitable. They absolutely can. But not if they’re poorly structured.

Without full staffing and a clear plan for what kind of work will be done, you’re spending money without seeing the return. You’re also risking technician burnout by asking them to give up their weekends for marginal gains.

The key is to match cost to output. If you’re running a half-day operation, expect half-day results. If you want more, you’ll need to structure Saturdays to deliver more.

Misalignment Between Availability and Capacity

There’s another side to this equation. Let’s say your customers love that you’re open Saturdays. That’s a win. But what happens if demand outpaces your capacity?

You could end up over-promising and under-delivering. Maybe customers are waiting three weeks for a Saturday slot. Or maybe they arrive to find a skeleton crew and delays they didn’t expect.

Either way, the experience falls short.

This is especially risky for first-time customers. A poor Saturday experience could push them to competitors who are better prepared to serve them on weekends.

Let’s say you’re consistently booking out your Saturday schedule. That tells you there’s demand. But if you’re only half-staffed, you’re letting opportunity slip through your fingers.

Even worse, your limited availability might steer customers into weekdays that are already crowded. That creates longer wait times, more pressure on advisors, and a ripple effect across your schedule.

It also impacts revenue forecasting. You may think demand is soft because weekday slots are going unfilled. But in reality, the customer who wanted Saturday gave up and went elsewhere.

When availability and capacity don’t match, everyone loses—your customers, your staff, and your bottom line.

One way to solve this is to treat Saturdays with the same strategic planning you use Monday through Friday. That means reviewing staffing levels, adjusting appointment types, and measuring technician output just like any other day.

You don’t need to turn Saturday into a carbon copy of a weekday. But you do need to make sure it’s designed to meet the level of business it brings in.

Turning Saturday Into a Real Asset

Saturdays can absolutely be valuable. But only if they’re aligned with your goals and structured to deliver results.

Start by measuring their actual output. Use the Saturday contribution method discussed earlier. Know how many equivalent workdays you’re really getting from your weekend hours.

If you find you’re only getting 1.4 days of output per month, ask yourself: can we increase that?

Here are some options.

First, look at your staffing. Can you rotate technicians so that every Saturday is fully staffed, even if each tech only works every third or fourth Saturday?

Can advisors take weekday time off in exchange for working Saturdays? That way, you’re not paying overtime, but you’re maintaining service continuity.

Next, define the kind of work you want to do on Saturdays. If you’re avoiding warranty work, is that a policy you can revisit? If you’re limiting repair types, is that based on actual risk or just old habits?

You might find that your shop can handle more complex jobs with a few changes to process and support.

Also, consider capacity planning. If you know Saturdays have a waitlist, try to shift some volume by offering early morning or extended weekday hours. Or create service packages that make Saturday more efficient, such as quick diagnostic appointments with follow-up scheduling.

Finally, track your Saturday performance. Measure hours sold per technician, appointment volume, and customer satisfaction. Treat it like any other business day.

The goal isn’t just to be open. It’s to be productive.

If Saturdays are booked solid, make sure you’re maximizing what you get out of each hour. If Saturdays are slow, dig into why. Is it staffing? Service mix? Marketing?

You won’t fix everything overnight. But with the right questions, clear numbers, and practical changes, Saturday can move from a drag on resources to a real contributor to your department’s success.

---

Elevate your Fixed Operations department with our custom-tailored solutions. Our team offers in-depth assessments and specialized training programs, crafting strategies designed specifically to boost efficiency, maximize customer retention, and ensure long-term profitability. We’ll work closely with you to identify areas for improvement and implement targeted solutions that drive sustainable growth for your business.

Contact us today for a Free Consultation!